Stainless Steel Grades: What Separates 304, 316L, 201, 430, 420 and 17-4PH

Stainless steel is defined by composition, not by behaviour. The definition is a chromium content of at least 10.5% with carbon below about 1.2%, and that is the whole of it. It promises a passive film that reforms in air. It does not promise that the part will not stain, will not pit in chloride, or will not crack in a welded assembly.

This page is a map of the grades a drawing is most likely to name, organised by the question that actually decides most selections: does the part have to be weldable and corrosion-resistant, does it have to be hard, or does it have to be cheap? Those three answers point at three different families, and choosing across families is a bigger decision than choosing within one.

The Definition, and What It Does Not Promise

The passive film is a chromium oxide layer a few nanometres thick that forms spontaneously and reforms after damage, provided oxygen is available. Every practical limitation of stainless steel follows from that qualifying clause. In an oxygen-free environment the film cannot reform, so a crevice, a gasket face or a stagnant pocket becomes the place corrosion starts.

Three failure modes are worth separating because they are often confused under the single word "rust":

  • General corrosion — uniform wastage in a strongly aggressive medium. Rare in correctly selected grades.
  • Pitting and crevice corrosion — localised attack driven by chloride, and the dominant failure mode in marine and process service. Molybdenum is the element that resists it.
  • Intergranular corrosion — chromium carbide precipitation at grain boundaries after welding or slow cooling through a sensitising range, which leaves chromium-depleted zones along the boundary. Low-carbon grades and stabilised grades exist to prevent it.

Five Families, Five Different Behaviours

FamilyStructureCan it be hardened by heat treatment?Common gradesWhere it fails
AusteniticFace-centred cubic, stabilised by nickel or manganeseNo — work hardens instead304, 316L, 201Chloride pitting and crevice attack; stress corrosion cracking in hot chloride; galling on threads
FerriticBody-centred cubic, chromium onlyNo430, 10Cr17Lower toughness and weldability; limited corrosion resistance in chloride
MartensiticBody-centred tetragonal after quenchingYes410, 420 seriesCorrosion resistance falls as hardness rises; brittle if over-hardened
Precipitation hardeningMartensitic or austenitic matrix plus ageing precipitatesYes, by ageing rather than quenching17-4PH (630)Hydrogen embrittlement risk at high strength; over-ageing if the ageing temperature drifts
DuplexMixed austenite and ferriteNo2205 and similarSigma-phase formation if held in the wrong temperature range

What Each Element Is Doing

ElementFunctionWhat changes when it is increased
Cr — chromiumForms the passive film; the defining elementBetter corrosion resistance up to a point; stabilises ferrite, which is why high-Cr grades need nickel to stay austenitic
Ni — nickelStabilises austenite; raises ductility and toughnessMore weldable and more formable, and more expensive
Mo — molybdenumResists pitting and crevice corrosion, particularly in chlorideThe single most useful addition for marine, salt and process service
C — carbonRaises strength and hardnessLowers weldability and corrosion resistance; the "L" suffix caps it at 0.03%
Mn — manganesePartially substitutes for nickel in stabilising austeniteCheaper grade at the cost of corrosion resistance; the basis of 201
Ti, Nb — titanium, niobiumCombine with carbon to prevent chromium carbide precipitationStabilised grades tolerate welding without sensitising; used where the L grades are not available

Austenitic: 304, 316L and 201

This is the family most machined parts are made from, and the two main grades have their own pages covering cutting behaviour, work hardening, thread quality and inspection. What matters at the selection level is the boundary between them and the existence of the third option.

  • 304 (06Cr19Ni10) — roughly 18% chromium and 8% nickel. The general-purpose grade: food equipment, sinks, housings, decorative parts, general corrosion-resistant structural work. It is the default and it is usually correct.
  • 316L (022Cr17Ni12Mo2) — adds 2–3% molybdenum and caps carbon at 0.03%. The molybdenum is what resists chloride pitting, which is why 316L rather than 304 is specified for marine atmospheres, salt contact, chemical service, medical parts and welded assemblies that cannot be solution annealed afterwards.
  • 201 — manganese replaces part of the nickel, at roughly 3.5–5.5% Ni instead of 8–11%. It is cheaper and it is visibly weaker in corrosion resistance. It performs acceptably indoors and in dry, low-chloride environments, and it fails quickly in humid, salty or acidic service. Where a 304 drawing has been quietly substituted with 201, the part usually looks right and rusts within a season.

Machining detail for the two main grades is on the 304 page and the 316 page. The 316 page also covers why 316 and 316L cannot be treated as interchangeable on a drawing that specifies one of them.

Ferritic: 430

10Cr17, with chromium around 16–18% and essentially no nickel. It is magnetic, it is inexpensive, it does not harden by heat treatment, and it has adequate corrosion resistance for indoor and mild outdoor service: appliance panels, decorative trim, kitchen equipment housings, automotive trim.

Its limits are toughness and weldability. 430 has a ductile-to-brittle transition and should not be specified for low-temperature service, and welding thick sections coarsens the grain and reduces toughness in the heat-affected zone. It is a good answer for a formed or machined cover and a poor one for a pressure boundary.

Martensitic: 410 and the 420 Series

These are the stainless grades that behave like steel: they harden by quenching, and their carbon content sets the achievable hardness.

GradeC (%)Hardness after hardeningCorrosion resistanceTypical use
410 / 12Cr13≤ 0.15ModerateModerateValve stems, shafts, turbine blades, general corrosion-resistant mechanical parts
420 / 20Cr130.16–0.25HigherReducedCutting tools, scissors, shafts, valve parts
420 / 30Cr130.26–0.35Higher againReduced furtherBlades, wear parts, surgical instruments
420 / 40Cr130.36–0.45Highest in the seriesLowest in the seriesCutting edges, wear-resistant corrosion-resistant parts

The trade is monotonic and unavoidable: every step up in carbon buys hardness at the cost of both toughness and corrosion resistance. A 40Cr13 part is a wear part that happens to resist rust, not a corrosion-resistant part that happens to be hard.

Precipitation Hardening: 17-4PH

05Cr17Ni4Cu4Nb, known outside China as 17-4PH or 630. Copper and niobium allow the alloy to be strengthened by a low-temperature ageing treatment rather than by quenching, which means it can be machined in the annealed condition, aged to final strength, and finish-machined with far less distortion than a quench-hardened grade would allow.

It reaches strength levels well above 304 while keeping useful corrosion resistance, which is why it appears in high-strength shafts, valve parts, pump shafts and precision mechanical components. Two cautions belong at the drawing stage: the ageing temperature determines the strength and toughness balance and must be specified, and high-strength PH stainless is susceptible to hydrogen embrittlement, which matters if the part will be plated.

The Magnet Test: What It Proves and What It Does Not

A magnet distinguishes families, not grades, and it is unreliable even at that.

ObservationWhat it suggestsWhy it is not conclusive
Non-magnetic or very weakly magneticAustenitic familyCold working — turning, thread rolling, bending — can transform some austenite to martensite and produce measurable magnetism in a genuine 304 part
Clearly magneticFerritic or martensitic familySome cast or heavily worked austenitic material is also weakly magnetic, and a heat-treated martensitic part can be strongly magnetic while a ferritic one is only mildly so
MixedDuplex, or a weld between familiesWelds, heat-affected zones and cold-worked surfaces all give mixed readings

The only reliable identification is composition analysis. Positive material identification by X-ray fluorescence or optical emission will read chromium, nickel, molybdenum, manganese and carbon, which is what actually determines the grade. On any part where grade substitution is a risk, a PMI check on the finished component is cheaper than the failure it prevents.

Equivalents

GB designationENAISI / SAEJISFamily
06Cr19Ni101.4301304SUS304Austenitic
022Cr17Ni12Mo21.4404316LSUS316LAustenitic
12Cr17Mn6Ni5N1.4372201SUS201Austenitic
10Cr171.4016430SUS430Ferritic
12Cr131.4006410SUS410Martensitic
20Cr131.4021420SUS420J1Martensitic
30Cr131.4028420SUS420J2Martensitic
40Cr131.4031420SUS420J2Martensitic
05Cr17Ni4Cu4Nb1.4542630 / 17-4PHSUS630Precipitation hardening

Matching the Family to the Failure Mode

What the part has to surviveGrade to consider
Indoor or mild outdoor corrosion, general machined parts304
Chloride, salt spray, marine atmosphere, chemical service, welded assemblies without post-weld anneal316L
Dry decorative service where cost dominates430, or 201 if formed rather than welded
Wear plus some corrosion resistance420 series, at the carbon level the wear demands
High strength with moderate corrosion resistance17-4PH
Seawater or chloride with high mechanical loadingDuplex, which is outside the scope of this page

What to Put in an RFQ

  • The grade designation together with the standard, since 420 alone spans three different carbon levels.
  • The condition: annealed, solution annealed, hardened and tempered to a stated hardness, or aged.
  • Whether the part will be welded, and whether post-weld treatment is possible.
  • The service environment in one line — inland, coastal, chloride contact, food contact, medical. It decides the grade more often than the drawing does.
  • Any requirement for certification of grade, and whether PMI on the finished part is expected.
  • The surface finish requirement, including whether passivation or pickling is expected after machining.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is 316 better than 304 for every application?

No. 316L resists chloride pitting better because of its molybdenum, and it is the right choice wherever chlorides are present. In non-chloride service 304 performs essentially as well, costs less and machines more easily. Specifying 316L by default adds cost without adding life, and specifying 304 by default in a coastal plant is the more expensive mistake of the two.

Why can 304 be slightly magnetic if it is not supposed to be?

Cold working partially transforms the austenitic structure into martensite, and martensite is magnetic. A turned surface, a rolled thread or a bent section will often read magnetic on a genuine 304 part while the core does not. This is why magnetism is not a valid acceptance test and why a supplier rejecting a part on a magnet reading is applying the wrong criterion.

Can 17-4PH be substituted for 304 when more strength is needed?

It can carry the load, and it changes three other things. Corrosion resistance in chloride is lower than 316L although better than 420, the part has to be aged to a specified temperature to reach its properties, and the higher strength makes it more sensitive to hydrogen embrittlement if it is subsequently plated. All three belong in the decision rather than being discovered after the first batch.

Need a Stainless Steel Component Machined?

DXSCNC machines drawing-based stainless components across the austenitic, martensitic and precipitation-hardening families: shafts, sleeves, bushings, threaded parts, fittings and flanged bodies.

Use the model-specific machining limits when planning a part. Material, geometry, tolerance, workholding and inspection affect machine selection.

Related DXSCNC resources: 304 Stainless CNC Turning, 316 Stainless CNC Machining, Preparing a Drawing Package for RFQ and Quality Inspection.

Request a Quote for Stainless Steel Machined Parts

Request a Quote